Wrongful Death Criminal Investigation

Chapter 150 4

After hearing this, Mingtang and the three of them were very shocked.

Didn't realize there were so many things in it.

Liang Sihan's revelations are still ongoing: "Qin Wang and his elder brother Qin Feng also have some conflicts. Qin Feng's grades are not good, he dropped out of school early and went to work in Guangdong Province, and later saved some money and came back to take his wife. Qin Feng is that person Weird and stubborn, Qin Feng’s parents lived in a house in their hometown, and now they moved to Yangjia Village. They used to live 3 kilometers away from here. After the death of Qin’s parents, Qin Feng chose to be an apprentice because of farming, and the house It was given to Qin Wang. Later, it was said that the expressway would be built from here. Maybe the Yang family village would be relocated, and the state would pay a sum of compensation. So Qin Feng had a big fight with Qin Wang, demanding to replace Qin with his own land. Qin Wang himself was not willing to change Wang's real estate, but Qin Feng went to the school to make trouble, and in the end he couldn't stand Qin Feng's troubles every day, so Qin Wang changed with them."

"It turned out that within two years, the house was demolished, and Qin Feng's family really got a bonus. The whole family moved to the original Biyang County, the current urban area. About 15 years ago, Qin Feng and Qin Wang The land that was exchanged, together with the cultivated land in other areas, was expropriated and compensated to 75W. Now Qin Feng and his family heard the news from it, and came to quarrel with Qin Wang again. It is said that the division of land and property was unfair , asking Qin Wang to give 30 to their family."

Qiu Shaoyang, Lu Changfeng, Mingtang: "..."

There are such outrageous people?

Liang Sihan also felt very helpless when he said it, "Of course Qin Wang didn't want to, but he couldn't stop his brother from bringing his wife to make trouble. At that time, his brother was almost 40 years old, and his brother's wife was also 37 years old. She was fat, and Qin Wang didn't know him. Brother's daughter-in-law was pregnant with the third child at the time. During the struggle, Qin Wang pushed his sister-in-law, but her sister-in-law had a miscarriage. Now Qin Wang was afraid that the trouble would affect him, so he gave them 20 yuan. , and received paperwork with them, you know, ten years ago, 20 was not a small amount, in Biyang County at that time, it was enough for them to buy a smaller house with full money on the edge of the county. But Greedy people can never be greedy. Qin Wang is also unlucky. With such a big brother, Qin Feng got cancer last year. Qin Feng's wife came to Qin Wang to ask for money to treat the disease. Qin Wang didn't give the money. As a result, Qin Feng Mrs. Feng made a big noise in the cram school. At that time, the college entrance examination was approaching, and many children needed a quiet environment. The parents of the students were also anxious. When they saw someone making trouble outside the cram school, they called the police directly, and took turns guarding outside the cram school. As soon as the Feng family came to make trouble, the parents of the students started to fight directly. After being beaten a few times, they stopped making trouble. Probably in July last year, Qin Feng died of cancer, and Qin Feng's wife has been pestering Qin Wang since then. I think it was his refusal to give his brother money that caused his brother to die in the hospital."

Lu Changfeng: "There's no police in charge of them? Qin Wang didn't call the police? In a society ruled by law, there are still people who are so lawless. It's too much!"

"The police also need the other party to have actual illegal acts." Liang Sihan sighed: "Qin Wang's sister-in-law is completely a dead pig and is not afraid of boiling water. Even if she is arrested and detained, she will be as troublesome as she comes out."

There are all kinds of outrageous people in this world.

"Then let her go on like this?" Lu Changfeng asked.

Liang Sihan said: "At first Qin Wang would fight back, but later Qin Wang also became numb."

"People are good at being bullied, and horses are good at being ridden." Ming Tang felt a little sympathetic to Qin Wang's experience: "If Qin Feng's family doesn't drain Qin Wang's value, they will not give up."

"Yes."

Ming Tang asked: "As far as you know, besides these few things, are there other things?"

"That's all I know."

On the way back to the Biyang Municipal Bureau, Lu Changfeng couldn't help complaining: "I have been handling cases for so many years, and I have seen all kinds of people, but I will still be annoyed if I meet such a person again."

Qiu Shaoyang also felt very speechless: "Normal, human nature cannot be generalized, especially the cases that we have been facing for a long time are some cases with bad influence, but if the cases are normal, this case will not be in our hands."

Mingtang agrees with Qiu Shaoyang's opinion: "As a front-line criminal policeman, this is what we face every day. Criminal policemen are also human beings with their own emotions and desires, as well as their own good and bad emotions."

Lu Changfeng sighed: "No matter how many years you have been in this industry, you still can't see the sufferings in the world."

Mingtang: "Not everyone in this world is a bad person, but we are fighting against the bad people. It is because we are fighting against the bad people that the world will be a better place."

Qiu Shaoyang said: "I think it's very strange. How could Kou Qing say that she has never had any disputes with anyone about such a big matter. With Qin Feng's family making such a disturbance, they are very suspicious of Qin Wang's death."

"I also don't understand why Kou Qing concealed this fact." Ming Tang said, "Not only Kou Qing, but also the village party secretary we met this afternoon, also said that he had no disputes with anyone. Why did they Do you want to say that?"

Lu Changfeng said: "Could it be that Liang Sihan is telling lies?"

Qiu Shaoyang shook his head: "I have observed his expression when he told these things, it doesn't look like he is telling lies, and most people dare not tell lies in front of the police, besides, he is a teacher, besides, whether it is Qin Feng's family messing around or Qin Wang who rowed the car and punctured the tires at the old man's house downstairs in the cram school all reported to the police, and you can find the police records by just checking, there is no need to risk such a lie, I prefer them to Kou Qing and they are hiding it."

Back at the Biyang Municipal Bureau, Xiao Ding Lanning, Yang Meng and the others were already waiting at the Municipal Bureau.

When they come back, the case discussion meeting will start immediately.

Ming Tang presided over the meeting, and Qiu Shaoyang and Lu Changfeng sat on the left and right of Ming Tang.

On Qiu Shaoyang's side were the other members of the Serious Crime Brigade, while Lu Changfeng's side were the main leaders of the Biyang City Bureau's Criminal Investigation Team, and everyone else sat on the seats behind them. In the case, Li Yanshan filed an application report with the higher-ups, and wanted to follow up the case throughout the process, so that his subordinates could learn the case-handling ideas of the Serious Crime Squad.

Therefore, Mingtang and the others came to Biyang this time not only to shoulder the heavy task of solving the case, but also to shoulder the task of teaching.

Mingtang said: "The 6.13 corpse case in the lake is our first meeting today to sort out the case. Yang Meng and Chen Yanjia, start with you and report the results of your investigation today."

Yang Meng was not good at words, so he handed over the reporter to Chen Yanjia. Chen Yanjia was also in charge of sorting out the information of the case. He put the deceased's information on the multimedia screen behind Ming Tang. Put them next to each other.

"Qin Wang, 43 years old, is from Qinjia Village, Yashan County, under the jurisdiction of Biyang City. His wife Kou Qing and daughter Qin Shuangyu are 17 years old. She is a sophomore in Yashan County High School. The body was found by the lake in Biyang Forest Park. The informant, Ms. Liu, was running by in the morning, found the body of the deceased, and then quickly reported the case."

"After our investigation in Qinjia Village today, the villager Qin Jiawang reported that at about 08:30, he saw Qin Wang passing by his door and going out of the village. Then the villager Qin Xiaofei recalled that he left work from the county at [-] o'clock. After returning home, I saw Qin Wang who was out of the village at the entrance of the village, and then the villager Qin Cheng reported that he was playing cards in the next village last night. Around [-]:[-], his wife called home and urged him to go home, so he returned from the next village On the way home, he saw Qin Wang halfway, he was very puzzled why Qin Wang had to go out in the middle of the night, and smelled of alcohol, he went to say that there was no wine at home, and went out to buy wine."

Qiu Shaoyang wrote it down in his notebook at this time, and he didn't know what he was thinking about.

Chen Yanjia continued: "According to Qin Cheng's testimony, we asked his wife, checked their call records, and checked with the villagers next door. Qin Cheng did receive his wife's call at around 08:30 last night. The phone left the next-door village, and tested it three times on an electric car according to the distance, and made an inference from the place he said he met Qin Wang. He probably met Qin Wang at 35:40 to 1:[-]. From the place where I met Qin Wang to their village, it takes about a minute to ride an electric bike."

"At about 40:[-], Qin Cheng returned to the village and passed the villager Qin Yu's house. He encountered Qin Yu and his wife arguing, so he went to persuade him to fight. At nine o'clock, Qin Cheng's wife hadn't seen Qin Yu coming home, so he gave him another He made a phone call. You can check the call records in the phone."

After Chen Yanjia listed the evidence, she continued: "We asked the villagers what kind of person Qin Wang was and whether he had offended anyone. They will all help."

There are three time nodes here.

Qiu Shaoyang asked: "Did Qin Xiaofei tell you what time he saw Qin Wang at the entrance of the village?"

Chen Yanjia shook her head: "He said he didn't remember the exact time. He rode a bicycle to work, and said that it usually took him 20-25 minutes to go home by bicycle, so we deduced that they were around 25:[-] to [-]:[-]." We met at the entrance of the village between ten and ten."

Ming Tang said: "Have you measured the distance from Qin Cheng's house to the entrance of the village and how many minutes it takes to walk?"

Chen Yanjia nodded: "I've tested it, the distance is about 1 kilometer, and the walking speed of a normal adult is 1.5m/s, which means it takes about 11-12 minutes. We also conducted a test, and Yang Meng's walking speed is almost 10 Minutes, while other police officers walk at will, almost all around 11-13 minutes. Calculated according to this speed, it is true that Qin Xiaofei met Qin Wang at the entrance of the village from 25:[-] to [-]:[-]. From the place where Qin Wang meets Qin Cheng, it is about another one kilometer. Based on this speed, it is also true that Qin Cheng will meet Qin Wang at around [-]:[-] to [-]:[-]."

Qiu Shaoyang said: "In the case of uniform speed, of course it is established, but don't forget that Qin Wang's blood alcohol content test value is very high, even if Qin Wang is drunk or close to drunk, the speed cannot be at a normal speed. The speed of an adult man is used as a reference, moreover, this time is too stuck and unreasonable."

"According to Qin Cheng and your tests, it takes him about 20-25 minutes to get to the village entrance from where he goes to work. If you count it as 25 minutes, counting the delay after work, the latest he arrives at the village entrance is 10 minutes. At 11:12, the time when Qin Jiawang and Qin Jiawang saw Qincheng was around 14:15, which was only 08 minutes. In a sober state, the speed of an adult is basically 30 km per [-] minutes, which is already relatively fast. The comprehensive average is [-] minutes. In the state, at least it will take [-]-[-] minutes. According to [-]:[-], the time when the villager Qin Jiawang saw Qin Wang was around [-]:[-] to [-]:[-], although this time seems to be It fits perfectly, there is no problem, but this is precisely the biggest problem. Everyone can give a detailed time, and the time of several people can be connected in series. When we see this series of time, what is the first reaction? ?”

Lu Changfeng said: "For the last testimony, Qin Cheng asked him what he was doing. He said that he went out to buy wine, and all the time points were completely stuck. Based on the testimony of these three time points, it can be basically concluded that Qin Wang left home."

"Yes, these important time points are conveying a concept to us, Qin Wang left home."

Qiu Shaoyang said: "When we arrived at Qin Wang's house, we found that his wallet, mobile phone, and keys were all at home. Since he was going to buy wine, and he could tell the villagers his destination, it showed that he was conscious He is still sober, how could he go out without money? But if he is unconscious, how can he be so tightly locked at every time point? This is a perfect chain of evidence, but Qin Shuangyu recorded in our recording During the confession, he said that the door was locked, and Qin Wang didn’t take the key to go out. Why was the door locked? But Kou Qing didn’t go home, so in reverse, if Qin Cheng didn’t meet Qin Wang on the road, Qin Xiaofei wouldn’t be at the entrance of the village either. Met Qin Wang, and Qin Jiawang didn't see Qin Wang passing by the door of his house, Qin Wang didn't even go out, and Qin Shuangyu lied about whether the door was locked or not, so the chain of evidence in this case can be deduced , can it also be established? 1+1=2 and 2-1=1 at the same time.”

After raising a series of questions, Qiu Shaoyang continued: "The forensic autopsy report said that the deceased died about an hour after eating, and Qin Shuangyu and the others usually had dinner around 07:30 in the evening, so the inferred time of death at that time was Between 08:30 and 50:60, according to the timeline provided by the villagers, this time happens to be when Qin Wang is not at home. So even if calculated according to this timeline, the distance from Qin Wang’s village to the county seat is about five kilometers, minus It took him about [-]-[-] minutes to walk to the county seat, and he walked five or six kilometers at night, just to go to the county seat to buy a drink, and he still walked Go? Is he crazy or are we crazy?"

A policeman said: "But what if he is not clear-headed at this time? Some people drink too much and do everything."

Qiu Shaoyang looked at the policeman who asked the question. It was a young policeman wearing glasses. Looking at the epaulettes on his shoulders, he should have just become a regular: "You can ask this question, which means you are also serious. Follow my way of thinking about this question, then, you substitute it, if you are Qincheng, you see your village, and if anyone is in trouble, you will lend a helping hand, and if you are drunk, you have to walk to the county town to buy wine. What will you do? Do you just let him go, or will you talk him out of it and let him go home?"

The policeman said: "Your explanation is a little too far-fetched. We handle the case based on the above information to make a judgment, rather than blindly relying on your personal inference."

Li Yanshan felt that all this happened again yesterday, as if he saw the scene where the detachment leader questioned Qiu Shaoyang again, and immediately stopped him sharply: "Bo Jiyang, shut up."

Qiu Shaoyang raised his hand to stop Li Yanshan's scolding, and Bo Jiyang explained: "It is true that the police should solve the case based on the facts, but the facts you see must be the real facts? The police handle the case, and the evidence is part of it." , experience is also part of it. The cause of death in this case was being smothered to death. Even if the village entrance and the road are not monitored, there is only one main road in the huge county. Combined with the time of death, according to your approval, the deceased was already at [-]:[-] They met Qin Cheng at the end of the day, and then Qin Cheng went home and Qin Wang continued to walk to the county town to buy wine, so the deceased Qin Wang could only have his mouth and nostrils covered with soft objects such as pillows and quilts on this road. As a result, it died, and the body was dumped by the lake in Biyang Forest Park. Is that right?"

Following this thought, Bo Jiyang nodded.

"If you think my analysis is wrong, then we can also divide it into two routes. You can see how many vehicles passed through the county town last night, and check them one by one during the corresponding time period, and then you can know what you think Is it the real truth?" Qiu Shaoyang said: "It is a good thing to have doubts, and it is also a good thing to make inferences based on the existing evidence. As a police officer alone, you need to distinguish the authenticity of the evidence. , if every police officer only believes the evidence he sees, how many cases will be wronged every year.”

Bo Jiyang said: "Even if the evidence is not all true, then what you said is reversed, and finally it is deduced that Qin Wang did not leave home at all, but died at home. What you mean is that all the villagers are lying. Team up to perjure the police? How likely do you think this is?"

Qiu Shaoyang smiled calmly: "Everyone has their own behavioral logic in doing things, so have you noticed in the photo just now that the trace inspection personnel at the scene collected evidence on the refrigerator of the deceased's house? There is frozen wine, and there is also wine at a constant temperature under the corner. It is not difficult to see from the decoration of the deceased's house that the deceased is a person who pays great attention to the arrangement of items. The classification of shoes on the shoe rack is also very regular. From this, we can also see It turns out that the logic of the deceased was very meticulous and his behavior was very regular. However, the pillows in the bedroom where the deceased lived were stacked and arranged randomly, but the quilt was neatly laid out on the bed. Since the deceased could arrange the quilt neatly, why were the pillows not placed evenly? According to the deceased's habit of placing objects, this violates his own habits."

"Going back to the time testimony provided by all the witnesses in this case, as well as the testimony of the deceased's daughter about the door lock, if you still think that there is nothing wrong with these testimony, then I can only say that you are not suitable to be a criminal policeman, because you believe in the superficial Evidence is easily confused. The police lose their ability to judge. When you face a vicious murderer, he is in front of you, but you pass him by. It is very likely that the next victim will be Die before your eyes."